Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: L3 reasoning re-authoring pass (2026-07-02) closed the remaining boilerplate-family defect found by the published-sample audit; see docs/GOAL_L3_REASONING_REAUTHORING_20260702.md.
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: Published-sample audit (2026-07-02) classified this article minor_defect: template boilerplate standing in for authored reasoning, contrary to the retired-template-composer rule. Report: docs/generated/published_sample_audit_report.md
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: Published-sample audit (2026-07-02) classified this article minor_defect: template boilerplate standing in for authored reasoning, contrary to the retired-template-composer rule. Report: docs/generated/published_sample_audit_report.md
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: Published-sample audit (2026-07-02) classified this article minor_defect: template boilerplate standing in for authored reasoning, contrary to the retired-template-composer rule. Report: docs/generated/published_sample_audit_report.md
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: Published-sample audit (2026-07-02) classified this article minor_defect: template boilerplate standing in for authored reasoning, contrary to the retired-template-composer rule. Report: docs/generated/published_sample_audit_report.md
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: Published-sample audit (2026-07-02) classified this article minor_defect: template boilerplate standing in for authored reasoning, contrary to the retired-template-composer rule. Report: docs/generated/published_sample_audit_report.md
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: Published-sample audit (2026-07-02) classified this article minor_defect: template boilerplate standing in for authored reasoning, contrary to the retired-template-composer rule. Report: docs/generated/published_sample_audit_report.md
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: Published-sample audit (2026-07-02) classified this article minor_defect: template boilerplate standing in for authored reasoning, contrary to the retired-template-composer rule. Report: docs/generated/published_sample_audit_report.md
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → published_beta
What changed: Reasoning sections re-authored (revision 1 -> 2): 'What is being inferred' and 'Why infer this entity' had verbatim pipeline boilerplate in place of argument. Evidence, scores, claims, and public status unchanged.
Why: Published-sample audit (2026-07-02) classified this article minor_defect: template boilerplate standing in for authored reasoning, contrary to the retired-template-composer rule. Report: docs/generated/published_sample_audit_report.md
Model-decided
2026-07-02
published_beta → draft
What changed: public_status: published_beta -> draft (demoted; review_needed, reversible).
Why: Adversarial re-judgement flagged a critical defect: The claim is framed around a specifically Alanian church-site pattern, but of the three substantive (non-process) evidence items, only one (the Senty inscription) ties directly to Alania; the second is counterevidence on Tkhaba-Yerdy's contested foundation date, and the third -- Pishchulina 2020, cited as *supporting* evidence -- explicitly states it 'links [Tkhaba-Yerdy] mainly with Kartli or Armenian architectural transmission rather than secure Alania.' The article's own cited source contradicts the specific 'Alania' attribution it is being used to support; the title and summary oversell a distinctly Alanian pattern that two of three evidence items do not actually establish. Combined with the same boilerplate non-reasoning sections as the sibling L3 inferon articles, this is evidence not entailing the claim as framed, not just a prose defect.